Office of the Court Administrator
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
1 Courthouse Square, Carlisle, PA 17013
Phone (717) 240-6200
Toll Free 1-888-697-0371 x6200
Fax (717) 240-6460
Email - courtadmin@ccpa.net
ARGUMENT COURT
Friday, December 6, 2019
Cases appearing on the Argument Court List will be heard as follows:
COURTROOM 3
Honorable GUIDO EDWARD E
Honorable BREWBAKER JESSICA E
Sitting En Banc Commencing at
9:30 AM
2 9:30 AM 2018-05974
Plaintiff: READING ANTHRACITE COMPANY
Defendant: WERTZ COAL YARD INC
DANIEL A WECHSLER, ESQ.
PLAINTIFF'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTION TO DEFENDANT'S RESPONSE
Listed September 24, 2019 by DANIEL A WESCHLER ATTY FOR PLFF
6 9:30 AM 2019-04915
Plaintiff: DEBORAH A ALLEN
Defendant: ZONING HEARING BOARD OF THE BOROUGH OF CARLISLE
DAVID A FITZSIMONS, ESQ.
APPELLANT'S LAND USE APPEAL
Listed October 3, 2019 by DAVID A FITZSIMONS ATTY FOR APPEALLANT
7 9:30 AM 2018-04994
Plaintiff: CALEB R HOOD; KATE M HOOD
Defendant: MYNDI LYNN BARNHART; DARIUS PROPERTIES; MILLRACE LLC
KEVIN D RAUCH, ESQ.; MARCUS A MCKNIGHT III, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed October 4, 2019 by KEVIN D. RAUCH -ATTY FOR DEFT
13 9:30 AM 2018-13410
Plaintiff: DEANNE BURCH; DEANNE M BURCH TRUST
Defendant: THE WOODS AT BRIDGEPORT; MICHAEL L MARTIN; MICHAEL L MARTIN INC; PROPERTY MANAGEMENT INC; YORK EXCAVATING CO LLC; YORK EXCAVATING COMPANY INC
ADLER CRAIG I, ESQ.; BARRY A KRONTHAL, ESQ.; Daniel Rothschild, Esq.; GLENN J SMITH, ESQ.; JENNIFER LYNN RUTH, ESQ.; Lisa Wojdak Basial, Esq.; MICHAEL R KELLEY, ESQ.; Mr. James A. Wells, Esq.; PETER J CARFLEY, ESQ.; Steven L Sugarman, Esq.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed October 24, 2019 by MICHAEL R KELLY ATTY FOR PLFFS
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed October 24, 2019 by MICHAEL R KELLEY ATTY FOR PLFFS
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed October 24, 2019 by MICHAEL R KELLEY ATTY FOR PLFFS
10:30 AM
5 10:30 AM 2018-06135
Plaintiff: S T L - EM LLC; S T L HOLDINGS LLC
Defendant: ENDLESS MOUNTAIN ENERGY PARTNERS LLC
ADAM S ENNIS, ESQ.; VERONICA L MORRISON, ESQ.
DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed October 1, 2019 by ORDER OF COURT DATED 9/30/2019
17 10:30 AM 2019-04428
Plaintiff: RAYMOND LYNCH; JEANETTA LYNCH
Defendant: GABLER TRUCKING INC; NATHAN HAWBAKER
Donald M Desseyn Esquire; J JEFFREY WATSON, ESQ.
DEFT PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFF COMPLAINT
Listed November 5, 2019 by DONALD M. DESSEYN - ATTY FOR DEFT
20 10:30 AM 2018-11244
Plaintiff: YORK REHAB & PAIN CONSULTANTS INC
Defendant: HEATH FREELAND
E HALEY ROHRBAUGH, ESQ.; KENNETH F LEWIS, ESQ.
PLFF MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS
Listed November 8, 2019 by E. HALEY ROHRBAUGH
COURTROOM 1
Honorable MASLAND ALBERT H
Sitting En Banc Commencing at
9:30 AM
1 9:30 AM 2018-03553
Plaintiff: TYLER T CAMPBELL
Defendant: MAINE DRILLING & BLASTING INC; ARCO DESIGN/BUILD NORTHEAST INC; DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA DBA PENNDOT
Alex Yoder, Esq.; JEREMY S MONTGOMERY, ESQ.; ORLANDO JOHN A, ESQ.; RANDALL M JUSTICE, ESQ.
DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed June 14, 2019 by ORDER OF COURT DATED 6/14/2019
3 9:30 AM 2019-02864
Plaintiff: ROBERT J HARPSTER
Defendant: MAHLON J BOYER ESQ; BINGAMAN HESS ATTORNEYS AT LAW
CHRISTOPHER E FISHER, ESQ.; Edwin A D Schwartz, Esq.; KENNETH W LEE, ESQ.
DEFENDANTS' PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed September 30, 2019 by NICOLE EHRHART ATTY FOR DEFTS
22 9:30 AM 2018-11566
Plaintiff: CAVALRY SPV I LLC
Defendant: KIMBERLY GUMBERT
DAVID J APOTHAKER, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed November 12, 2019 by NICHOLAS FOPPIANO ATTY FOR PLFF
23 9:30 AM 2019-03080
Plaintiff: CAVALRY SPV I LLC
Defendant: TERRI KNOCH
DAVID J APOTHAKER, ESQ.
DEFTS PRILIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed November 12, 2019 by NICHOLAS FOPPIANO ATTY FOR PLFF
10:30 AM
4 10:30 AM 2014-04709
Plaintiff: MICHAEL MCCLEARY; MICHAEL MCCLEARY
Defendant: CATHERINE STAUFFER; JAY STAUFFER
LISA J MAUER, ESQ.; RONALD M GRAHAM, ESQ.
DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed October 1, 2019 by JOSEPH A MACALUSO ATTY FOR DEFTS
8 10:30 AM 2018-02131
Plaintiff: RICKY HECK; SHAWNA HECK
Defendant: BRIDGE INSURANCE AND FINANCIAL SERVICES INC
Donnell Much, Esq.; GARTH G HOYT, ESQ.; Glenn Gitomer, Esq.; Jean Bickhart, Esq.; VERONICA L MORRISON, ESQ.
PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL PURSUANT TO ORDER OF COURT DATED 10/1/2019
Listed October 9, 2019 by DONNELL MUCH ATT FOR PLFFS
10 10:30 AM 2017-08839
Plaintiff: PACIFIC UNION FINANCIAL LLC; MR COOPER; NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE LLC
Defendant: MISHALA S JONES
BRIAN T LAMANNA, ESQ.; JACOB M OTTLEY, ESQ.; JEFFREY C BRIGHT, ESQ.; STEPHEN K PORTKO, ESQ.
PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed October 21, 2019 by JEFFREY C BRIGHT ATTY FOR PLFF
11 10:30 AM 2019-01269
Plaintiff: RICHARD A POST; MARLENE J POST
Defendant: EMMANUEL BAPTIST CHURCH OF WEST SHORE
GREGORY R REED, ESQ.; JOSHUA A REED, ESQ.; SHAWN P MCLAUGHLIN, ESQ.
DENIAL OF DEFENDANT'S ARGUMENT APPOSING PO'S - SEE ATTACHED EXHIBIT A AND AFFIDAVIT
Listed October 23, 2019 by JOSHUA A REED ESQ ATTY FOR PLFFS
18 10:30 AM 2018-09474
Plaintiff: TRACY SMITH; M S
Defendant: BILL L STINE
Abbie Trone, Esq.; GERARD C KRAMER, ESQ.; SUSAN R ENGLE, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed November 7, 2019 by SUSAN R ENGLE
11:30 AM
15 11:30 AM 2019-05307
Plaintiff: MICHAEL KALINICH
Defendant: DENA TRIPAS
Thomas P. Clark, Esq.; TIMOTHY A SHOLLENBERGER, ESQ.
DEFENDANT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PUNITIVE DAMAGES IN PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT
Listed November 4, 2019 by TIMOTHY A SHOLLENBERGER ATTY FOR PLFF
BRIEFS ONLY
Honorable PECK CHRISTYLEE L
Sitting En Banc Commencing at
0:00 AM
9 0:00 AM 2019-04834
Plaintiff: JEFFREY J SEIBERT ADMINSITRATOR; ROY J BIELICKI DECEASED
Defendant: HCR MANORCARE INC; HCR HEALTHCARE LLC; HCR II HEALTHCARE LLC; HCR III HEALTHCARE LLC; HCR IV HEALTHCARE LLC; HCR MANOR CARE SERVICES LLC; HCR MANORCARE HEARTLAND LLC; HCR MANORCARE LLC; HCR MANORCARE OPERATIONS II LLC; HCRMC OPERATIONS LLC; HEARTLAND EMPLOYMENT SERVICES LLC; MANOR CARE INC; MANOR CARE OF CARLISLE PA LLC DBA MANORCARE HEALTH SERVICES -CARLISLE; MORCARE HEALTH SERVICES INC AKA MANORCARE HEALTH SERVICES LLC
Christine C Blair, Esq.; Dianna Magdolna Hall, Esq.; John B. Zonarich, Esq.; JOHN M SKROCKI, ESQ.; Kristin Hoffman, Esq.; RUBEN J KRISZTAL, ESQ.; WILLIAM J MUNDY, ESQ.
DEFENDANT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed October 17, 2019 by COREY S YOUNG ATTY- PLFF
19 0:00 AM 2019-06652
Plaintiff: PARTNERS FOR PAYMENT RELIEF DE IV LLC; PARTNERS FOR PAYMENT RELIEF DE IV LLC
Defendant: DAVID M COLE
DAVID A BARIC, ESQ.; JILL M FEIN, ESQ.; LAUREN L SCHULER, ESQ.
PLAINTIFFS RESPONSES TO DEFENDANTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed November 7, 2019 by LAUREN L SCHULER ATTY FOR PLFF
Removed from Argument
12 removed 2019-06666
Plaintiff: MARK BOISEY
Defendant: WILLIAM ALBRECHT III
KEVIN L HALL, ESQ.; SHAWN M STOTTLEMYER, ESQ.
PLFF PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO COUNTER CLAIMS OF DEFT
Listed October 24, 2019 by KEVIN L. HALL -ATTY FOR PLFF
Reason: Stipulation
16 removed 2019-05119
Plaintiff: HASSAN MAYHEW
Defendant: ADAM HUBER
FULGINITI JOSEPH, ESQ.
DEFENDANTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO THE AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed November 5, 2019 by JOSEPH FULGINITI ATTY- DEFT
Reason: Pending Settlement Agreement
14 removed 2019-07012
Plaintiff: STEVEN HOWELL; BERIT T HOWELL ESTATE OF
Defendant: ROBERT J BULGARELLI D.O.; MARGRETTA J AMEIGH M.D.; BRET DELONE M.D.; FAMILY PRACTICE CENTER PC; PAUL KUNKEL M.D.; KRISHNA NEMANI M.D.
BAKER LAURALEE B, ESQ.; Carol M Cowhey, Esq.; DANIEL P MARTZ, ESQ.; JOSEPH G ZACK, ESQ.; PETER FABEN, ESQ.; RIEDERS CLIFFORD A, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANTS MARGRETTA AMEIGH M.D. AND FAMILY PRACTICE CENTER, P.C. TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed October 29, 2019 by BY PETER J FABEN ATTY FOR DEFTS
Reason: Moot
21 removed 2019-07072
Plaintiff: EMILY STOVER
Defendant: DANIEL RICHARD MORRISON
DOUGLAS C LOVELACE JR, ESQ.
DEFENDANTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed November 8, 2019 by DOUGLAS C LOVELACE JR ATTY FOR PLFF
Reason: Settled