Office of the Court Administrator
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
1 Courthouse Square, Carlisle, PA 17013
Phone (717) 240-6200
Toll Free 1-888-697-0371 x6200
Fax (717) 240-6460
Email - courtadmin@ccpa.net
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
1 Courthouse Square, Carlisle, PA 17013
Phone (717) 240-6200
Toll Free 1-888-697-0371 x6200
Fax (717) 240-6460
Email - courtadmin@ccpa.net
ARGUMENT COURT
Friday, May 17, 2024
Cases appearing on the Argument Court List will be heard as follows:
COURTROOM 3
Honorable GUIDO EDWARD E
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Honorable SIBERT MICHELLE H
Honorable GUIDO EDWARD E
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Honorable SIBERT MICHELLE H
Sitting En Banc Commencing at
9:30 AM
| 2 | 9:30 AM | 2023-01358 |
Plaintiff: DOBSON PARK MANAGMENT LLC; LEONARD J DOBSON FAMILY LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
Defendant: SELECT PORTFOLIO SERVICING INC; MR COOPER
BRYAN W SHOOK, ESQ.; Nicholas Borsuk, Esq.
PRELIMNARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed January 16, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| 8 | 9:30 AM | 2023-04498 |
Plaintiff: PATRICIA B HUTTER EXECUTRIX ; ESTATE OF RAY E HUTTER JR DECEASED
Defendant: MECHANICSBURG SENIOR CARE LLC DBA VIBRA REHABILITATION CENTER AKA VIBRALIFE MECHANICSBURG; HOLLINGER MANAGEMENT LLC; MECHANICSBURG SENIOR CARE HOLDINGS LP DBA VIBRA REHABILITATION CENTER AKA VIBRALIFE MECHANICSBURG; MREC LLP DBA VIBRA REHABILITATION CENTER AKA VIBRALIFE MECHANICSBURG; VIBRA HEALTHCARE LLC; VIBRA HEALTHCARE MANAGEMENT LLC; VIBRALIFE PERSONAL CARE AKA VIBRA REHHABILITATION CENTER AKA VIBRALIFE MECHANICSBURG
Brian L Strauss, Esq.; Ryan J. King, Esq.; Sean Bollman, Esq.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed January 23, 2024 by BY SEAN BOLLMAN - ATTY FOR DEFT
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed February 2, 2024 by SEAN T BOLLMAN
|
| 20 | 9:30 AM | 2024-00661 |
Plaintiff: JEFF FREEZE
Defendant: WEST SHORE POLICE ASSOCIATION INC; NEW CUMBERLAND BOROUGH
Brett C. Flower, Esq.; Logan Hetherington, Esq.; MILLER MICHAEL MCAULIFFE, ESQ.; Nathan McGrath, Esq.; Richardson Todd Eagen, Esq.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed February 16, 2024 by BY RICHARD TODD EAGEN - ATTY FOR DEFT
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed February 22, 2024 by BY BRETT FLOWER - ATTY FOR DEFT
DEFTS WEST SHORE POLICE ASSOCIATION INC PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed March 15, 2024 by RICHARDSON TODD EAGEN
|
| 24 | 9:30 AM | 2024-00002 |
Plaintiff: MATTHEW FARST
Defendant: AUTOZONE INC
Ari Marcus, Esq.; Michael Jervis, Esq.
TO PLFFS COMPLAINT BASED ON LACK OF IN PERSONAM AND SUBJECT MATTER JURISDICTION AND IN THE NATURE OF A DEMURRER
Listed February 27, 2024 by MICHAEL JERVIS ATTY FOR DEFT
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed March 21, 2024 by ARI H MARCUS - ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| 33 | 9:30 AM | 2020-04616 |
Plaintiff: KRISTI L MARSH
Defendant: DYLON K HOBART; FILSON WATER LLC
Edwin L Stock, Esq.; JOSHUA J BOVENDER, ESQ.
DEFT FILSON WATER LLCS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed March 14, 2024 by EDWIN L STOCK
|
| 37 | 9:30 AM | 2020-01627 |
Plaintiff: LESTER ASSOCIATES ; GATEWAY SQUARE ASSOCIATES
Defendant: SCOTT APPEL ; BIG BOBS FLOORING OUTLET; BIG BOBS FLOORING ; BIG BOBS FLOORING ; BIG BOBS FLOORING OUTLET; BIG BOBS FLOORING OUTLET; BIG BOBS FLOORINGS; TOUCH OF COLOR ; TOUCH OF COLOR DESIGN GROUP INC ; TOUCH OF COLOR FLOORING INC
Alexandria Ebbert, Esq.; EVAN C PAPPAS, ESQ.; KATIE J MAXWELL, ESQ.; KAYLA M ZIZZI, ESQ.; TRAVIS L KREISER, ESQ.
PER 3/28/2024 ORDER OF COURT - DOCKET ENTRY FOR ARGUMENT COURT PURPOSES
Listed April 16, 2024 by BY THE COURT: EDWARD E GUIDO J -
|
| 39 | 9:30 AM | 2023-05941 |
Plaintiff: ALLERGAN USA INC
Defendant: GLO SKIN CARE LLC DBA GLO SKIN CARE MD
Lloyd S Markind, Esq.
IN RE: CONTINUANCE
Listed April 22, 2024 by BY THE COURT: EDARD E GUIDO J -
|
BRIEFS ONLY
Honorable GUIDO EDWARD E
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Honorable SIBERT MICHELLE H
Honorable GUIDO EDWARD E
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Honorable SIBERT MICHELLE H
Sitting En Banc Commencing at
0:00 AM
| 3 | 0:00 AM | 2023-07120 |
Plaintiff: JOHN W KICHMAN
Defendant: DONALD M WOOD; BARBARA L WOOD
Ralph Crelin, Esq.
DEFT PRELIMINARY OBJECTION TO PLFF COMPLAINT
Listed January 16, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed March 26, 2024 by DARRELL C DETHLEFS
|
| 4 | 0:00 AM | 2023-10678 |
Plaintiff: PAULANA MARIE ANTCZAK
Defendant: ALEXANDER ODONNELL-COLELLA; ABC CO 1-10; BEACON FUNDING CORPORATION; JOHN DOE 1-10; OLIVIA FILBURN; ANDREW LEHMAN
Christopher A Bradley, Esq.; Jacqueline Promislo, Esq.; Kevin F Farrington, Esq.; Kira Rivera, Esq.; Sami Zeka, Esq.; SEAN PATRICK O'MAHONEY, ESQ.; WADE D MANLEY, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed January 16, 2024 by BY JACQUELINE PROMISLO - ATTY FOR DEFT
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed January 16, 2024 by BY JACQUELINE PROMISLO - ATTY FOR DEFT
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed February 20, 2024 by BY JACUELINE PROMISLO - ATTY FOR DEFT
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed February 20, 2024 by JACQUELINE PROMISLO - ATTY FOR DEFTS
|
| 5 | 0:00 AM | 2023-10908 |
Plaintiff: ; BEN J RHODES; ELIZABETH I RHODES
Defendant: ELMA C BYERS
CORYN D. HUBBERT, ESQ.; SALLY J WINDER, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT
Listed January 18, 2024 by CORYN D HUBBERT
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed February 6, 2024 by BY CORYN D HUBBERT - ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 7 | 0:00 AM | 2023-09043 |
Plaintiff: UNIVERSAL PROTECTIVE PACKAGING INC; TIMOTHY RITTER; RODNEY RUMBERGER
Defendant: JEFFREY BILLMAN
Bingran Li, Esq.; James Christopher Froelich, Esq.; LEROY SMIGEL, ESQ.
PLFFS MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS
Listed January 18, 2024 by LEROY SMIGEL ESQ
|
| 9 | 0:00 AM | 2024-00240 |
Plaintiff: CITIBANK NA
Defendant: VICKEY HORVATH
GEORGE B FALLER JR, ESQ.; MATTHEW W POMY, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed January 25, 2024 by BY BRADLEY GRIFFIE - ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| 10 | 0:00 AM | 2023-05325 |
Plaintiff: MARK I MARTIN
Defendant: DAVID J RAUDABAUGH; JOYCE A RAUDABAUGH; SABLE CHASE DEVELOPMENT
ANTHONY T LUCIDO, ESQ.; Jeffrey Schott, Esq.
DEFT PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFF COMPLAINT
Listed January 29, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 11 | 0:00 AM | 2023-06548 |
Plaintiff: WILMINGTON SAVINGS FUND SOCIETY FSB NOT IN ITS INDIVIDUAL CAPACITY; WILMINGTON SAVINGS FUND SOCIETY FSB NOT IN ITS INDIVIDUAL CAPACITY
Defendant: DENNIS MCCOMMONS
LORRAINE GAZZARA DOYLE, ESQ.; MICHAEL J CLARK, ESQ.; ROBERT W WILLIAMS, ESQ.; STEPHEN M HLADIK, ESQ.; Thomas C Dyer, Esq.; WARREN LEVY, ESQ.
PLFFS MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS
Listed January 30, 2024 by ROBERT W WILLIAMS
|
| 13 | 0:00 AM | 2024-00241 |
Plaintiff: CITIBANK NA
Defendant: KEISHLA ILLA
GEORGE B FALLER JR, ESQ.; MATTHEW W POMY, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTION
Listed February 7, 2024 by BY GEORGE B FALLER JR - ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 14 | 0:00 AM | 2023-09187 |
Plaintiff: 21ST MORTGAGE CORPORATION ET AL
Defendant: CHARLOTTE L SHEFFIELD; HUTCH HOMES INC
Charles Jones, Esq.; ELIZABETH SMITH, ESQ.; Jessica S Kaczinski, Esq.; KANDICE KERWIN HULL, ESQ.; Kellie Rahl-Heffner, Esq.; MICHAEL S TRAVIS, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS OF PLFF TO DEFT HUTCH HOMES JOINDER COMPLAINT
Listed February 8, 2024 by KELLIE RAHL-HEFFNER
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed March 1, 2024 by CHRISTINA L CONNOR - ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| 15 | 0:00 AM | 2023-05081 |
Plaintiff: DORIS E BRYTZ
Defendant: WEICHERT WORKFORCE MOBILITY; WEICHERT RELATORS FIRST CHOICE
ALESIA S SULOCK ESQ; Alicia M Sandoval, Esq.; Frank C Sluzis, Esq.; GLEN D KIMBALL, ESQ.; MICHAEL J PYKOSH, ESQ.
MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS
Listed February 9, 2024 by ALESIA S SULOCK
|
| 19 | 0:00 AM | 2023-03106 |
Plaintiff: RONALD WHEELER
Defendant: PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS
IMPROPER SERVICE
Listed February 16, 2024 by SANDRA KOZLOWSKI
|
| 21 | 0:00 AM | 2023-02829 |
Plaintiff: ALLY BANK
Defendant: JERRY L CUSTER; JENNIFER A CUSTER
BRIAN YODER, ESQ.; CAROLYN TREGLIA, ESQ.; HELBING ERIK M, ESQ.; ROSEMARIE DIAMOND, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed February 16, 2024 by BY BRIAN YODER - ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| 22 | 0:00 AM | 2023-03476 |
Plaintiff: DISCOVER BANK
Defendant: JOSHUA A MONIGHAN
WILLIAM T MOLCZAN, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed February 21, 2024 by JOSHUA MONIGHAN
|
| 23 | 0:00 AM | 2024-00668 |
Plaintiff: CITIBANK N A
Defendant: KEITH E AUCKER
MICHAEL R LIPINSKI, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.; SEAN STEVENS, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT
Listed February 22, 2024 by BY ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 25 | 0:00 AM | 2024-00042 |
Plaintiff: BRIAN L MAHER
Defendant: ALPHA QUALITY & PERFORMANCE MOTORSPORTS LLC
DERYCK HENRY, ESQ.; GERARD J PISARCIK, ESQ.; W SCOTT STARUCH, ESQ.
DEFT PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT
Listed February 29, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 26 | 0:00 AM | 2024-01270 |
Plaintiff: CITIBANK N A
Defendant: TRACEY S REAM
Ilana Zion, Esq.; MICHAEL R LIPINSKI, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.; SEAN STEVENS, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed March 1, 2024 by BY ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH - ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 27 | 0:00 AM | 2016-04205 |
Plaintiff: NATIONAL COLLEGIATE STUDENT LOAN TRUST 2007-2 A DELAWARE STATUTORY TRUSTS
Defendant: ROBERT L ANDERSON
GREGG L MORRIS, ESQ.
MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS
Listed March 1, 2024 by BY GREGG L MORRIS ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| 28 | 0:00 AM | 2023-05611 |
Plaintiff: CITIBANK NA
Defendant: ANN M FELIX
MATTHEW W POMY, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed March 5, 2024 by BY ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH - ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 29 | 0:00 AM | 2024-00888 |
Plaintiff: ERIE INSURANCE EXCHANGE A/S/O CATHERINE DEMBOWSKI
Defendant: NB MECHANICAL SERVICES INC
CORYN D. HUBBERT, ESQ.; DEMETRIOS H TSAROUHIS, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed March 5, 2024 by BY CORYN HUBBERT - ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 30 | 0:00 AM | 2023-06295 |
Plaintiff: EDWARD GRAZIANO
Defendant: PENNSYLVANIA DEPT OF CORRECTIONS ; CO BOYD ; CO FONTAINE; DOUGLAS DICKEY; ROSS MILLER
FULGINITI JOSEPH, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO THE AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed March 6, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 36 | 0:00 AM | 2023-07606 |
Plaintiff: HORIZON FARM CREDIT ACA
Defendant: SCOTT W KETTERER
ADAMS STEVEN J, ESQ.
PLFFS MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS PURSUANT TO PA R CIV P 1034
Listed March 25, 2024 by STEVEN ADAMS
|
| 38 | 0:00 AM | 2023-10058 |
Plaintiff: TIMOTHY SAUNDERS
Defendant: SCI CAMP HILL SUPERINTENDENT MICHAEL GOURLEY
ABBY N TROVINGER, ESQ.
PER ORDER OF COURT - DOCKET ENTRY CREATED FOR ARGUMENT COURT LIST PURPOSES
Listed April 22, 2024 by BY THE COURT: EDWARD E GUIDO J -
|
Removed from Argument
| 1 | removed | 2023-08644 |
Plaintiff: STEPHEN G MARCUS
Defendant: VIBRA HEALTHCARE LLC
CORY A LESHNER, ESQ.; Douglas Yohe, Esq.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed January 14, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| Reason: Settled | |||
| 6 | removed | 2023-10688 |
Plaintiff: PATRICIA D MAINHART
Defendant: TAWANDA STALLWORTH; WANDA HUNTER; CHRIS STALLWORTH
Bedrudin Becirovic, Esq.; SEAN M SHULTZ, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed January 18, 2024 by BY BEDRUDIN BECIROVIC ESQ
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed February 14, 2024 by MIDDLE DISTRICT COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA
|
| Reason: Discontinued | |||
| 12 | removed | 2023-10583 |
Plaintiff: S C; E B
Defendant: CARLISLE AREA SCHOOL DISTRICT
GARY H DADAMO, ESQ.; Joseph Santarone, Esq.; NATHANIEL FOOTE, ESQ.; VERONICA N HUBBARD, ESQ.
DEFT CARLISLE AREA SCHOOL DISTRICTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT
Listed January 31, 2024 by JOSEPH J SANTARONE
|
| Reason: Withdraw PO's | |||
| 18 | removed | 2023-03697 |
Plaintiff: LAKEVIEW LOAN SERVICING LLC
Defendant: CANDICE J BURNS; KEVIN J RUDY
Geraldine M. Linn, Esq.; SEAN M DUFFY, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO DEFTS ANSWER
Listed February 13, 2024 by SEAN DUFFY
|
| Reason: Discontinued | |||
| 31 | removed | 2024-00890 |
Plaintiff: DEAN E PIFER; KATHI L PIFER
Defendant: TIM PIERCE
SUZANNE H GRIEST, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed March 7, 2024 by BY SUZANNE H GRIEST - ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| Reason: Discontinued | |||
| 32 | removed | 2007-07109 |
Plaintiff: GNANA M CHINNIAH; GNANACHANDRA M CHINNIAH; SUGANTHINI CHINNIAH
Defendant: EAST PENNSBORO TOWNSHIP ; JEFFREY S SHULTZ
CHRISTOPHER S UNDERHILL, ESQ.; CORYN D. HUBBERT, ESQ.; DONALD L CARMELITE, ESQ.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed March 8, 2024 by BY DONALD CARMELITE - ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| Reason: Dismissed/Closed | |||
| 35 | removed | 2022-06677 |
Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER CRUZ
Defendant: AMES; AMES TRUE TEMPER INC; COLUMBIA PENNSYLVANIA TRUE TEMPER OFFICE PROPERTIES LLC; JOHN DOE 1; JOHN DOE 2; MBS SOLUTIONS INC ; MILLER BROTHER STAFFING SOLUTIONS LLC; PENGATE HANDLING SYSTEMS INC; RAYMOND HANDLING SOLUTIONS INC; THE AMES COMPANIES INC; THE RAYMOND CORPORATION
Ali Audi, Esq.; Glenn M. Campbell, Esq.; Richard B, Wickersham Jr., Esq.; THOMAS SACCHETTA, ESQ.; Valerie Kellner, Esq.; William J. Ricci, Esq.
DEFT PENGATEHANDLING SYSTEMS INCS MOTION TO COMPEL MORE SPECIFIC DISCOVER RESPONSES DIRECTED TO PLFF
Listed March 25, 2024 by RICHARD B WICKERSHAM JR
MOTION TO SEEM ADMITTED
Listed March 25, 2024 by RIACHRD B WICKERSHAM - ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| Reason: Removed per Court Order | |||
| 34 | removed | 2022-09312 |
Plaintiff: JOHN E RIPKA III
Defendant: BARRY LEE GRAMM; FISHER AUTO PARTS INC
ADAM G REEDY, ESQ.; Laura Daube, Esq.; MATTHEW R CLAYBERGER, ESQ.
DEFTS MOTION FOR JUDGDMENT ON THE PLEADINGS
Listed March 19, 2024 by LAURA C DAUBE
|
| Reason: Requested 6/28 | |||
| 16 | removed | 2023-09316 |
Plaintiff: CARLISLE SENIOR HOUSING ASSOCIATES
Defendant: HARRISON E WRIGHT
DAVID A BARIC, ESQ.; Jillian Copeland, Esq.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed February 12, 2024 by BY DAVID A BARIC - ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| Reason: Cont. to 6/28 per Court Order | |||
| 17 | removed | 2023-09899 |
Plaintiff: CARLISLE SENIOR HOUSING ASSOCIATES
Defendant: LESTER L MILLER
DAVID A BARIC, ESQ.; Jillian Copeland, Esq.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed February 12, 2024 by BY DAVID BARIC - ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| Reason: Cont. to 6/28 per Court Order | |||