Office of the Court Administrator
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
1 Courthouse Square, Carlisle, PA 17013
Phone (717) 240-6200
Toll Free 1-888-697-0371 x6200
Fax (717) 240-6460
Email - courtadmin@ccpa.net
ARGUMENT COURT
Friday, August 2, 2024
Cases appearing on the Argument Court List will be heard as follows:
COURTROOM 3
Honorable GUIDO EDWARD E
Honorable SMITH MATTHEW P
Honorable SIBERT MICHELLE H
Sitting En Banc Commencing at
9:30 AM
7 9:30 AM 2021-02175
Plaintiff: BRYAN CRUMMEL
Defendant: LINDSEY COSTELLO; JEFFREY COSTELLO; JESSE WEBB
JOHN A STATLER, ESQ.; MICHAEL B SCHEIB, ESQ.; REGINA M MCILVAINE, ESQ.; Stephen M HICKEY, Esq.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OF DEFT PRESIDENTIAL TRUCK LEASING LLC
Listed April 11, 2024 by STEPHEN M HICKEY
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed April 12, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed May 16, 2024 by BY STEPHEN M HICKEY - ATTY FOR DEFT
28 9:30 AM 2022-05596
Plaintiff: GUNN-MOWERY LLC
Defendant: P BRIAN FLOYD; PAMELA J BARBUSH; EPIC INSURANCE BROKERS AND CONSULTANTS; DAVID SCHLOSBERG
BLOOM JONATHAN F, ESQ.; DANA WINDISCH CHILSON, ESQ.; Edwin A D Schwartz, Esq.; ELIZABETH SMITH, ESQ.; Joseph W Catuzzi, Esq.; MARK D BRADSHAW, ESQ.; Michael D. O'Mara, Esq.; STEINOUR YOUNG CAROL A, ESQ.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS
Listed May 10, 2024 by Y MARK D BRADSHAW - ATTY FOR DEFT
34 9:30 AM 2022-05192
Plaintiff: JACK JAROH; JANEAL JAROH
Defendant: TREVOR MATTHEWS; MATTHEWS CONSTRUCTION AKA MATTHEWS CONSTRUCTION LLC AKA MATTHEWS CONSTRUCTION SERVICES LLC AKA MATTHEWS CONSTRUCTION HOME IMPROV
GUY MERCOGLIANO, ESQ.; JOSHUA J BOVENDER, ESQ.; Laura Daube, Esq.; Logan A Nagle, Esq.; MARCUS EDWARD ABRAMSON, ESQ.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed May 17, 2024 by BY GUY MERCOGLIANO - ATTY FOR DEFT
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed June 13, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
BRIEFS ONLY
Honorable GUIDO EDWARD E
Honorable SMITH MATTHEW P
Honorable SIBERT MICHELLE H
Sitting En Banc Commencing at
0:00 AM
2 0:00 AM 2024-02377
Plaintiff: CAPITAL ONE
Defendant: JOHN S MOSHER
MICHAEL F RATCHFORD, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed April 8, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed May 1, 2024 by ROBERT KLINGENSMITH
5 0:00 AM 2023-10913
Plaintiff: STEPHANIE SEVCIK; DEREK SEVCIK
Defendant: AMY COMISKEY; MICHAEL COMISKEY
JASON E PIATT, ESQ.; PETER J RUSSO, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed April 9, 2024 by BY JASON PIATT - ATTY FOR PLFF
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed April 9, 2024 by BY JASON PIATT - ATTY FOR PLFF
6 0:00 AM 2023-04876
Plaintiff: MATTHEW RAPOPORT
Defendant: NAPA TRANSPORTATION INC
CUMMINGS DERREK W, ESQ.; LARRY A WEISBERG, ESQ.; Leah A. Lewis, Esq.; Michael Bradley, Esq.; Steve Mahan, Esq.; Susan Valinis, Esq.; Tracey McDevitt Hagan, Esq.
TO PLFFS COMPLAINT
Listed April 10, 2024 by SUSAN M VALINIS
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed April 29, 2024 by BY STEVE T MAHAN - ATTY FOR PLFF
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed May 17, 2024 by BY SUSAN M VALINIS - ATTY FOR DEFT
8 0:00 AM 2023-10558
Plaintiff: SHERRI HOCKLEY ARHONDAKIS; TAYLOR ARHONDAKIS
Defendant: CHRISTOPHER DARHOWER; ALWAYZ DOWN TO FETCH LLC; JOY TICHNELL
ANDREW PATRICK, ESQ.; Ann Rinear Dougherty Esquire; Jacqueline Schneiders, Esq.; Kristina Bergsten, Esq.
OF DEFTS CHRISTOPHER DARHOWER JOYEL TICHNELL AND ALWAYZ DOWN TO FETCH LLC TO PLFFS SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed April 11, 2024 by JACQUELINE E SCHNEIDERS
9 0:00 AM 2024-02819
Plaintiff: PENNSYLVANIA STATE EMPLOYEES CREDIT UNION
Defendant: SHANE FINN
MATTHEW D URBAN, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS PURSUANT TO PA R C P 1028
Listed April 18, 2024 by ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH
10 0:00 AM 2024-02408
Plaintiff: JPMORGAN CHASE BANK NA
Defendant: DONALD I NELSON II
Ian Michael Lauer, Esq.; James A HOLZMAN, Esq.; Julie E Goodchild, Esq.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed April 19, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR PLFF
11 0:00 AM 2021-06913
Plaintiff: JUSTIN SHOEMAKER
Defendant: JC BAR PROPERTIES INC
DANA WINDISCH CHILSON, ESQ.; Dominic Giovanniello, Esq.; Edwin A D Schwartz, Esq.; FINCK RONALD L, ESQ.; James A. Beebe, Esq.; JAMES L GOLDSMITH, ESQ.; Lauren Anthony, Esq.
PLFF PREIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed April 22, 2024 by BY RONALD FINCK ATTY FOR PLFF
12 0:00 AM 2024-02865
Plaintiff: DETRICK CURTIS CONERLY
Defendant: H&R BLOCK CORPORATION JEFF JONES CEO
Casey Hunt, Esq.
DEFT PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed April 22, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
13 0:00 AM 2024-01870
Plaintiff: NEWREZ LLC DBA SHELLPOINT MORTGAGE SERVICING
Defendant: ZACHARY M DUGAN
Cierra-Zadiyah Mendez, Esq.; Kayleigh Zeron, Esq.; M TROY FREEDMAN, ESQ.; Nicole Rizzo, Esq.; Zachary DuGan, Esq.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed April 23, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
15 0:00 AM 2024-02779
Plaintiff: FULTON BANK NA
Defendant: CHARLES LOWELL KERN AKA CHARLES L KERN
HEATHER A EGGERT, ESQ.; MARC A HESS, ESQ.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT PURSUANT TO PA R C P 1035.2
Listed April 29, 2024 by MARC A HESS
18 0:00 AM 2024-03281
Plaintiff: CITIBANK NA
Defendant: JANET L MISTISHIN
MATTHEW W POMY, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS PURSUANT TO PA R C P 1028
Listed April 30, 2024 by ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH
19 0:00 AM 2024-00001
Plaintiff: JOSEPH DIEVA
Defendant: MANOR CARE OF CARLISLE PA LLC; 940 WALNUT BOTTOM ROAD OPERATIONS; ABC CORP 1 THROUGH 10; GENESIS PM PA OPERATIONS LLC; JOHN/JANE DOES 1 THROUGH 10; XYZ CO 1 THROUGH 10
Alexander B Possino Esquire; AMIE M. GOLEN, ESQ.; Bryan Reid, Esq.; Jessica Foster, Esq.; Marc T. Thirkell, Esq.; SEAN PATRICK O'MAHONEY, ESQ.
OF DEFT MANOR CAR OF CARLISLE PA LLC D/B/A PROMEDICA SKILLED NURSING AND REHABILITATION (CARLISLE) TO PLFFS AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed May 1, 2024 by CONNOR E REED
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS OF DEFT MANOR CARE OF CARLISLE PA LLC D/B/A PROMEDICA SKILLED NURSING AND REHABILITATION CARLISLE TO PLFFS AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed June 21, 2024 by SEAN P OMAHONEY
23 0:00 AM 2023-08343
Plaintiff: DISCOVER BANK
Defendant: MELISSA FRANK
ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
TO AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed May 9, 2024 by ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH
24 0:00 AM 2023-08179
Plaintiff: DISCOVER BANK
Defendant: GAIL BARNETT
ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
PURSUANT TO PARCP 1028
Listed May 9, 2024 by ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH
26 0:00 AM 2020-06348
Plaintiff: VICTORIA HINES; ORA M CROPLEY
Defendant: KENS PLUMBING INC; EK SERVICES INC; PENNSYLVANIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
CHRISTOPHER M REESER, ESQ.; Glenn M. Campbell, Esq.; JAYNE A GARVER, ESQ.
PLFFS COMPLAINT
Listed May 10, 2024 by CHRISTOPHER M REESER ATTY FOR DEFT PENNSYLVANIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
27 0:00 AM 2024-03737
Plaintiff: CITIBANK N A
Defendant: MELISSA K FRANK
Ilana Zion, Esq.; MICHAEL R LIPINSKI, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.; SEAN STEVENS, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed May 10, 2024 by BY ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH - ATTY FOR DEFT
29 0:00 AM 2024-03733
Plaintiff: PATRIOT-NEW CO
Defendant: CUMBERLAND VALLEY SCHOOL DISTRICT; CUMBERLAND COUNTY TAX
J STEPHEN FEINOUR, ESQ.; JOSHUA D BONN, ESQ.; Keith O Brenneman, Esq.; MICHAEL J CASSIDY, ESQ.; STARLIN COLON, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed May 13, 2024 by ATTY FOR DEFTS
DEFT CUMBERLAND VALLEY SCHOOL DISTRICTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT
Listed May 13, 2024 by MICHAEL CASSIDY ESQ
30 0:00 AM 2024-02127
Plaintiff: FNB; FIRST NATIONAL INSURANCE AGENCY LLC
Defendant: KENNETH MAZZIE
Deborah Ann Gearhart, Esq.; KIMBERLY A BONNER, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS REPLY TO NEW MATTER AND ANSWER TO COUNTERCLAIMS
Listed May 13, 2024 by DEBORAH GEARHART ESQ
31 0:00 AM 2022-09393
Plaintiff: U S BANK TRUST NATIONAL ASSOCIATION NOT IN ITS INDIVIDUAL CAPACITY BUT SOLELY AS TRUSTEE OF LSRMF MH MASTER PARTICIPATION
Defendant: JOHN W CLENDENIEN
ANDREW C SHEELY, ESQ.; ANDREW L MARKOWITZ, ESQ.; Dana Marks, Esq.; DANIELLE JOHNSON, ESQ.
OF DEFTS KEVIN CLEDNENIEN, KARLA CRAIG AND PATRICIA KUEHN TO PLFFS AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed May 15, 2024 by ANDREW C SHEELY
32 0:00 AM 2021-02594
Plaintiff: LESLIE ONEGLIA; SERGIO ONEGLIA
Defendant: RICHARD DUGAN; RIX ROOFING
Jack W. Burke, Esq.; RANDALL M JUSTICE, ESQ.; Susan Valinis, Esq.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed May 15, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
33 0:00 AM 2022-02326
Plaintiff: WELLS FARGO BANK NA
Defendant: EUGENE A RODGERS; VALERIE S RODGERS
Cierra-Zadiyah Mendez, Esq.; HARRY B REESE, ESQ.; M TROY FREEDMAN, ESQ.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR IN THE ALTERNATIVE MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS
Listed May 16, 2024 by HARRY B REESE
35 0:00 AM 2023-07512
Plaintiff: LVNV FUNDING LLC
Defendant: STACY A MUNIER
J CHAD MOORE, ESQ.; James A HOLZMAN, Esq.; Julie E Goodchild, Esq.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed June 3, 2024 by JULIE E GOODCHILD
36 0:00 AM 2023-00584
Plaintiff: FLAGSHIP CREDIT ACCEPTANCE
Defendant: GILBERT MAGARO; MAGAROS AUTO SALES AND TOWING
ANDREW P CONDILES, ESQ.; JAMES W KOLLAS, ESQ.; MICHAEL J DOUGHERTY, ESQ.
PLFFS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO DEFTS COUNTERCLAIM
Listed June 19, 2024 by MICHAEL J DOUGHERTY
Removed from Argument
1 removed 2015-05825
Plaintiff: DENNIS J WEAVER
Defendant: GOLD STAR GENERAL CONSTRUCTION LLC; HARVEY H LEID
MICHAEL A SCHERER, ESQ.; PETER J RUSSO, ESQ.; SHAWN C WESTHAFER, ESQ.
PER ORDER OF COURT
Listed April 2, 2024 by
Reason: listed for trial, not Argument Court
3 removed 2024-01962
Plaintiff: TIFFANY NOVAK
Defendant: SAMUEL PALUMBO
BRANDON T HUGHEY, ESQ.; HUBERT X GILROY, ESQ.; JOHN A ABOM, ESQ.; KAREN L DEMARCO, ESQ.; LISA MARIE COYNE, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO COMPLAINT
Listed April 9, 2024 by KAREN L DEMARCO
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed May 17, 2024 by BY KAREN L DEMARCO - ATTY FOR DEFT
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed June 18, 2024 by BRANDON T HUGHEY - ATTY FOR PLFF
Reason: Cont. to Sept
14 removed 2011-09059
Plaintiff: HEIDI MOSER SPINELLI
Defendant: ROBERT C SPINELLI
DEBRA CANTOR, ESQ.; MARC A SCARINGI, ESQ.; TERESA M MARINO, ESQ.
MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed April 26, 2024 by MARC A SCARINGI - ATTY FOR DEFT
Reason: moot - court order
16 removed 2024-03274
Plaintiff: BANK OF AMERICA
Defendant: JINWON KIM
GEORGE B FALLER JR, ESQ.; JONATHAN P CAWLEY, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed April 29, 2024 by BY GEORGE B FALLER JR - ATTY FOR DEFT
Reason: amended complaint filed
17 removed 2023-01409
Plaintiff: WILLIAM R FREY
Defendant: JEFFREY L CASSELL; WENDY J CASSELL
KARA W HAGGERTY, ESQ.; PETER J RUSSO, ESQ.; SHAWN C WESTHAFER, ESQ.; WALTER A. TILLEY III, ESQ.
DOCKET ENTRY CREATED FOR ARGUMENT COURT PURPOSES
Listed April 30, 2024 by PER 2/20/2024 ORDER OF COURT BY THE COURT: MICHELLE H SIBERT J -
Reason: no motions to argue
20 removed 2023-08483
Plaintiff: ERIE INSURANCE EXCHANGE ASO CAPITAL PLAZA ASSOCIATES LP
Defendant: OPTILUMEN INC; HORNUNG’S TRUE VALUE INC ; VIDEO MANAGEMENT INDUSTRIES INC
Anthony Ziccardi, Esq.; CHOMKO JEFFREY J, ESQ.; JEFFREY M POLLOCK, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO DEFTS JOINDER COMPLAINT
Listed May 6, 2024 by CLEM C TRISCHER
Reason: amended complaint filed
21 removed 2023-01358
Plaintiff: DOBSON PARK MANAGMENT LLC; LEONARD J DOBSON FAMILY LIMITED PARTNERSHIP
Defendant: SELECT PORTFOLIO SERVICING INC; MR COOPER
BRYAN W SHOOK, ESQ.; Nicholas Borsuk, Esq.
DEFT PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed May 8, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
Reason: Guido already ruled on the PO's
22 removed 2024-02968
Plaintiff: STACY L BROWN; RODNEY E BROWN SR
Defendant: KELLER CONTRACTING LLC; ENGLES AND FAHS INC
Amanda L Hennessey, Esq.; BARRY A KRONTHAL, ESQ.; STEPHEN G HELD, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed May 9, 2024 by BY JOHN CROUMER ATTY FOR PCS INC DEFT
DEFT DELAUDER MECHANICAS LLCS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT BY AMANDA L HENNESSEY ATTY FOR DEFTS
Listed May 10, 2024 by AMANDA L HENNESSEY ATTY FOR DEFTS
Reason: amended complaint filed
25 removed 2017-05256
Plaintiff: ATLANTIS POOLS INC
Defendant: DARRYL K GUISTWITE; MICHELLE L GUISTWITE
ANDREW H SHAW, ESQ.; PETER J RUSSO, ESQ.; Shaw Andrea L Shaw, Esq.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed May 10, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
Reason: amended complaint filed
4 removed 2024-01105
Plaintiff: HALEY WEIBLEY
Defendant: SYNCREON AMERICA INC
BRIAN C CAFFREY, ESQ.; Erica Shikunov, Esq.; Jeffrey Schott, Esq.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed April 9, 2024 by BY EILEEN KEFE - ATTY FOR DEFT
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed May 16, 2024 by BY EILEEN KEEFE - ATTY FOR DEFT
Reason: Stip