Office of the Court Administrator
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
1 Courthouse Square, Carlisle, PA 17013
Phone (717) 240-6200
Toll Free 1-888-697-0371 x6200
Fax (717) 240-6460
Email - courtadmin@ccpa.net
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
1 Courthouse Square, Carlisle, PA 17013
Phone (717) 240-6200
Toll Free 1-888-697-0371 x6200
Fax (717) 240-6460
Email - courtadmin@ccpa.net
ARGUMENT COURT
Friday, November 8, 2024
Cases appearing on the Argument Court List will be heard as follows:
COURTROOM 3
Honorable GUIDO EDWARD E
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Honorable SMITH MATTHEW P
Honorable GUIDO EDWARD E
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Honorable SMITH MATTHEW P
Sitting En Banc Commencing at
9:30 AM
| 2 | 9:30 AM | 2017-09350 |
Plaintiff: BECKY BARRICK
Defendant: DENNIS HAMILTON; SUN LIGH CUSTOMS
CHAD J JULIUS, ESQ.; GEORGE B FALLER JR, ESQ.; Robert David O'Brien, Esq.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed June 27, 2024 by ATTY FOR PLFF
SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON A COUNTER CLAIM BASED ON THE FAILURE TO PRODUCE ANY EVIDENCE ON DAMAGES AND IN FAVOR OF PLFF BASED ON ADMISSIONS IN THE PLEADINGS
Listed July 31, 2024 by BY GEORGE B FALLER JR ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| 18 | 9:30 AM | 2024-00002 |
Plaintiff: MATTHEW FARST
Defendant: AUTOZONE INC
Ari Marcus, Esq.; Michael Jervis, Esq.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS AMENDED COMPLAINT BASED ON LACK OF SUBJECT MATTER AND IN PERSONAM JURISDICTIONAND IN THE NATURE OF A DEMURRER
Listed July 29, 2024 by MICHAEL JERVIS ATTY FOR DEFT
DEFT PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed August 19, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| 30 | 9:30 AM | 2023-07023 |
Plaintiff: MELANIE HORVATH
Defendant: AMERICAN WATER WORKS COMPANY INC; AMERICAN WATER WORKS SERVICE COMPANY INC; PENNSYLVANIA AMERICAN WATER COMPANY
Ashley Baxter, Esq.; Max O. Bernstein, Esq.; Michael J. Puma, Esq.; Rahul Munshi, Esq.; Sean Caulfield, Esq.
DEFT PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed September 26, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
BRIEFS ONLY
Honorable GUIDO EDWARD E
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Honorable SMITH MATTHEW P
Honorable GUIDO EDWARD E
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Honorable SMITH MATTHEW P
Sitting En Banc Commencing at
0:00 AM
| 1 | 0:00 AM | 2024-05510 |
Plaintiff: CKS PRIME INVESTMENTS
Defendant: STEPHANIE A HOLLEN
Gail Hills, Esq.; JOEL M FLINK, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed June 26, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 3 | 0:00 AM | 2024-05104 |
Plaintiff: CITIBANK N A
Defendant: SHEILA WEEMS
Ilana Zion, Esq.; MICHAEL R LIPINSKI, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.; SEAN STEVENS, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS PURSUANT TO PARCP 1028
Listed June 28, 2024 by ROBERT KLINGENSMITH
|
| 4 | 0:00 AM | 2024-01850 |
Plaintiff: CITIBANK N A
Defendant: GEORGE ANN SWEGER
Ilana Zion, Esq.; JOHN S BENNETT, ESQ.; MICHAEL R LIPINSKI, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.; SEAN STEVENS, ESQ.
PRELIMINRY OBJECTIONS
Listed July 1, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 5 | 0:00 AM | 2021-02640 |
Plaintiff: KEITH DRAIN; DEMETRIUS BAILEY
Defendant: CORRECTIONAL OFFICER JAMES ; CORRECTIONAL OFFICER HUBER ; CORRECTIONAL OFFICER KAUFFMAN; SGT JEN DIGBY
Tara J Wikhian, Esq.
DEFT HUBERS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO COMPLAINT
Listed July 2, 2024 by TARA J WIKHIAN ESQ
|
| 6 | 0:00 AM | 2022-01353 |
Plaintiff: ANGELA C WEST; CHRISTIAN C BOGANS; ANGELA C WEST-BOGANS
Defendant: US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION ; TRACY C BOGANS; SUNTRUST NOW TRUIST
RICHARD J NALBANDIAN, ESQ.; STEVEN M WILLIAMS, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT
Listed July 2, 2024 by RICHARD J NALBANDIAN ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 7 | 0:00 AM | 2024-06007 |
Plaintiff: CITIBANK NA
Defendant: ELLEN JOERGER KITZ
NICHOLAS DEENIS, ESQ.; PAUL JOHN KLEMM, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS PURSUANT TO PA R C P 1028
Listed July 3, 2024 by ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH
|
| 8 | 0:00 AM | 2024-02968 |
Plaintiff: STACY L BROWN; RODNEY E BROWN SR
Defendant: KELLER CONTRACTING LLC; ENGLES AND FAHS INC
Amanda L Hennessey, Esq.; BARRY A KRONTHAL, ESQ.; STEPHEN G HELD, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed July 10, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
TO PLFFS SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed July 12, 2024 by AMANDA L HENNESSEY
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed July 12, 2024 by BY JOHN W CROUMER ATTY FOR DEFT PCS INC
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS OF DEFT ENGLES AND FAHS INC TO THE SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT OF PLFFS STACY L BROWN AND RODNEY E BROWN SR
Listed July 15, 2024 by BARRY KRONTHAL ESQ
|
| 11 | 0:00 AM | 2024-00668 |
Plaintiff: CITIBANK N A
Defendant: KEITH E AUCKER
MICHAEL R LIPINSKI, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.; SEAN STEVENS, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS PURSUANT TO PA R.C.P. 1028
Listed July 15, 2024 by ROBERT KLINGENSMITH ESQ
|
| 12 | 0:00 AM | 2024-05536 |
Plaintiff: CITIBANK N A
Defendant: TODD DRAZIEN
Ilana Zion, Esq.; MICHAEL R LIPINSKI, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.; SEAN STEVENS, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS PURSUANT TO PA R.C.P. 1028
Listed July 15, 2024 by ROBERT KLINGENSMITH ESQ
|
| 13 | 0:00 AM | 2023-04529 |
Plaintiff: E H; LYNNSEY HOUGHTON; MICHAEL HOUGHTON
Defendant: CARLISLE CHRISTIAN ACADEMY; JAMES KOSER; ANNA MCCAUSLIN; CHAD MCCAUSLIN
BARRY A KRONTHAL, ESQ.; Chante N DePersia, Esq.; CHRISTOPHER GLENN MAVROS, ESQ.; Daniel Rothschild, Esq.; STEVEN R SNYDER, ESQ.
MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS
Listed July 22, 2024 by
|
| 15 | 0:00 AM | 2024-05370 |
Plaintiff: KEVIN GREEN
Defendant: SCI CAMP HILL ; SUPERINTENDENT MICHARL GOURLEY
Tara J Wikhian, Esq.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO COMPLAINT
Listed July 25, 2024 by TARA J WIKHIAN ATTY FOR DEFT
ORDER OF COURT
Listed August 26, 2024 by
|
| 16 | 0:00 AM | 2024-03516 |
Plaintiff: HARRY & DONNA ARNOLD
Defendant: THE GUTTER GUYS
JASON P MCNICHOLL, ESQ.
OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT
Listed July 29, 2024 by BY JASON P MCNICHOLL ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 19 | 0:00 AM | 2021-05214 |
Plaintiff: DANIEL M LANIOUS
Defendant: ROBERT LEE MCGUGIN
GARTH GARTIN, ESQ.; MARCUS A MCKNIGHT III, ESQ.; MARK A MARTINI, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT
Listed August 1, 2024 by MARK MARTINI ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 20 | 0:00 AM | 2024-00717 |
Plaintiff: UMAR ALI
Defendant: FOOTLOCKER CORP ET EL; RONALD DIMM; STEFFI LINARES
Brian M Lands, Esq.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed August 6, 2024 by BRIAN LANDIS ESQ
|
| 21 | 0:00 AM | 2024-06406 |
Plaintiff: CITADEL FEDERAL CREDIT UNION
Defendant: BRYAN K TATE; STEVEN W DUPERT SR
DAVID R GALLOWAY, ESQ.; GEORGE B FALLER JR, ESQ.; MATTHEW D URBAN, ESQ.; MATTHEW W POMY, ESQ.
DEFT STEVEN W DUPERT SRS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed August 7, 2024 by GEORGE B FALLER JR ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 23 | 0:00 AM | 2021-02175 |
Plaintiff: BRYAN CRUMMEL
Defendant: LINDSEY COSTELLO; JEFFREY COSTELLO; JESSE WEBB
JOHN A STATLER, ESQ.; MICHAEL B SCHEIB, ESQ.; REGINA M MCILVAINE, ESQ.; Stephen M HICKEY, Esq.
DEFT MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed August 28, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 26 | 0:00 AM | 2024-07906 |
Plaintiff: PENNSYLVANIA STATE EMPLOYEES CREDIT UNION
Defendant: SHERRY A HAINES
MATTHEW D URBAN, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed September 12, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 29 | 0:00 AM | 2020-06339 |
Plaintiff: ISHA SESAY
Defendant: SHIPPENSBURG UNIVERSITY; JOHN DOE
Benjamin C Hoffman, Esq.; JEREMY S MONTGOMERY, ESQ.; Robert A Dengler, Esq.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed September 16, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 25 | 0:00 AM | 2024-01367 |
Plaintiff: MEMBERS 1ST FEDERAL CREDIT UNION
Defendant: RICKY LYNCH
PAULA J MCDERMOTT, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed September 9, 2024 by PAULA J MCDERMOTT
PER ORDER OF COURT
Listed September 10, 2024 by
|
Removed from Argument
| 10 | removed | 2024-00252 |
Plaintiff: PENNSYLVANIA STATE EMPLOYEES CREDIT UNION
Defendant: ELIZABETH JOHNSON JANIS; ELIZABETH JANIS; WAYNE JANIS; WAYNE A JANIS
BENJAMIN N HOEN, ESQ.; STEVEN HOWELL, ESQ.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed July 12, 2024 by BENJAMIN N HOEN ESQ ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| Reason: discontinued | |||
| 14 | removed | 2024-03808 |
Plaintiff: SUSAN I COPEING; SUSAN COPEING AS EXECUTRIX OF THE ESTATE OF DAVID R FOY
Defendant: CREEK SENIOR CARE LLC DBA BRIDGES AT BENT CREEK ; RESIDENTIAL HOSPICE OF CARLISLE LLC
ANTHONY J GABRIEL, ESQ.; Kristin Hoffman, Esq.; KYLE C ALLEN, ESQ.; MICHAEL M BADOWSKI, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTION OF DEFT CREEK SENIOR CARE LLC BRIDGES AT BENT CREEK TO PLFFS COMPLAINT
Listed July 22, 2024 by BY MICHAEL M BADOWSKI ATTY FOR DEFT CREEK SENIOR CARE LLC DBA BRIDGES AT BENT CREEK
|
| Reason: . | |||
| 17 | removed | 2024-04501 |
Plaintiff: BARRY BAILEY; BARRY BAILEY
Defendant: CLAREMONT NURSING & REHABILITATION CENTER LLC ; ABC CORP 1 THROUGH 10; ALLAIRE HEALTH SERVICES INC; JOHN/JANE DOES 1 THROUGH 10; BENJAMIN KURLAND; XYZ CO 1 THROUGH 10
Bryan Reid, Esq.; Jessica Foster, Esq.; Thomas Mark Savon, Esq.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT
Listed July 29, 2024 by BY THOMAS M SAVON ATTY FOR DEFTS
|
| Reason: . | |||
| 28 | removed | 2023-04100 |
Plaintiff: KATHERINE STRAIT; DANIEL STRAIT
Defendant: GRAYSON RALPH BOWERS
Ann Rinear Dougherty Esquire; BREYMEIER JOSEPH A, ESQ.; KELLY TREWELLA, ESQ.; Kristina Bergsten, Esq.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed September 16, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| Reason: . | |||
| 27 | removed | 2023-05992 |
Plaintiff: STUDENT LOAN SOLUTIONS LLC
Defendant: JOHANNA ESTRADA
ANDREW SKLAR, ESQ.; James K. Jones, Esq.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed September 13, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| Reason: Settlement Agreement | |||
| 22 | removed | 2022-06743 |
Plaintiff: PRECISION BALANCING INC
Defendant: PRESBYTERIAN DEVELOPMENT LLC; 2500 GETTYSBURG ASSOCIATES LLC
Aaron Scheibelhut, Esq.; John A. Gagliardi, Esq.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS BY ATTY FOR DEFT
Listed August 16, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| Reason: Settle and Discontinue | |||
| 9 | removed | 2023-01008 |
Plaintiff: UPPER ALLEN TOWNSHIP
Defendant: STEPHEN J GUTSHALL; 1ST ADVANTAGE SETTLEMENT SERVICES INC; SHERRY M CASWELL; HOOVER ENGINEERING SERVICES INC; JOHN N PAPOUTSIS
Bingran Li, Esq.; ELIZABETH L MELAMED, ESQ.; FREDERICK M BREHM, ESQ.; J STEPHEN FEINOUR, ESQ.; JOSHUA D BONN, ESQ.; LAVERY FRANK J JR, ESQ.; LINUS FENICLE, ESQ.; MADISON BIERLEY, ESQ.; Matthew G. Laver, Esq.; MURRAY J WEED, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS OF ADDITIONAL DEFT JOHN N PAPOUTSIS ESQ TO THIRD PARTY COMPLAINT OF DEFTS STEPHEN J GUTSHALL AND SHERRY M CASWELL EXECUTORS OF THE ESTATE OF JAMES M GUTSHALL AND TO CROSSCLAIM OF DEFT HOOVER ENGINEERING SERVICES INC
Listed July 10, 2024 by MATTHEW O SANYOUR ATTY FOR DEFT
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS OF DEFT 1ST ADVANTAGE SETTLEMENT SERVICES INC TO THE THIRD PARTY COMPLAINT OF STEPHEN J GUTSHALL AND SHERRY M CASWELL EXECUTORS OF THE ESTATE OF JAMES M GUTSHALL
Listed August 8, 2024 by ATTY FOR DEFT
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed October 11, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed October 14, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| Reason: move to December term | |||
| 24 | removed | 2024-03921 |
Plaintiff: J C
Defendant: PAIN RELIEF CHIROPRACTIC PC; STINAS HERBCRAFT AND MASSAGE THERAPY
JOHN CROUMER, ESQ.; KONSTANTINOS PATSIOPOULOS, ESQ.; KUTZ JAMES J, ESQ.; NATHANIEL FOOTE, ESQ.; VERONICA N HUBBARD, ESQ.
DEFT PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed September 3, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| Reason: move to December | |||