Office of the Court Administrator
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
1 Courthouse Square, Carlisle, PA 17013
Phone (717) 240-6200
Toll Free 1-888-697-0371 x6200
Fax (717) 240-6460
Email - courtadmin@ccpa.net
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
1 Courthouse Square, Carlisle, PA 17013
Phone (717) 240-6200
Toll Free 1-888-697-0371 x6200
Fax (717) 240-6460
Email - courtadmin@ccpa.net
ARGUMENT COURT
Friday, December 13, 2024
Cases appearing on the Argument Court List will be heard as follows:
COURTROOM 4
Honorable SMITH MATTHEW P
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Honorable SIBERT MICHELLE H
Honorable SMITH MATTHEW P
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Honorable SIBERT MICHELLE H
Sitting En Banc Commencing at
9:00 AM
| 5 | 9:00 AM | 2023-01008 |
Plaintiff: UPPER ALLEN TOWNSHIP
Defendant: STEPHEN J GUTSHALL; 1ST ADVANTAGE SETTLEMENT SERVICES INC; SHERRY M CASWELL; HOOVER ENGINEERING SERVICES INC; JOHN N PAPOUTSIS
Bingran Li, Esq.; ELIZABETH L MELAMED, ESQ.; FREDERICK M BREHM, ESQ.; J STEPHEN FEINOUR, ESQ.; JOSHUA D BONN, ESQ.; LAVERY FRANK J JR, ESQ.; LINUS FENICLE, ESQ.; MADISON BIERLEY, ESQ.; Matthew G. Laver, Esq.; MURRAY J WEED, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS OF ADDITIONAL DEFT JOHN N PAPOUTSIS ESQ TO AMENDED THIRD PARTY COMPLAINT OF DEFTS STEPHEN J GUSTHALL AND SHERRY M CASWELL EXECUTORS OF TH ESTATE OF JAMES M GUTSHALL AND TO AMENDED CROSSCLAIM OF DEFT HOOVER ENGINEERING SERVICES INC
Listed August 19, 2024 by MATTHEW O SANYOUR
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS OF DEFT 1ST ADVANTAGE SETTLEMENT SERVICES INC TO THE AMENDED THIRD PARTY COMPLAINT OF STEPHEN J GUTSHALL AND SHERRY M CASWELL EXECUTORS OF THE ESTATE OF JAMES M GUTSHALL
Listed September 16, 2024 by ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 17 | 9:00 AM | 2023-07151 |
Plaintiff: TYLER BROWN
Defendant: THE PEP BOYS - MANNY MOE JACK LLC; CBRE GROUP INC ; FACILITYSOURCE HOLDING LLC; ROXANNE L CRAWFORD EXECUTRIX FOR THE ESTATE OF RODNEY L WITMER D/B/A AR WITCO
Brian J Hinkle, Esq.; Joan Marie Etzweiler, Esq.; JULIANN SCHWEGLER KELLEY, ESQ.; KELLY LLP TOOMEY C SCOTT, ESQ.; LLOYD SUSAN SMITH, ESQ.
TO PLFFS COMPLAINT
Listed September 18, 2024 by SUSAN SMITH LLOYD
Listed October 31, 2024 by
|
| 21 | 9:00 AM | 2022-02296 |
Plaintiff: JAMES BRUMBACH; SUZANNE BRUMBACH
Defendant: DARREN DUNWOODY
MICHAEL E KOSIK, ESQ.; Shannon Harkins, Esq.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OF DEFT DARREN DUNWOODY
Listed September 25, 2024 by SHANNON HARKINS
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed November 1, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
BRIEFS ONLY
Honorable SMITH MATTHEW P
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Honorable SIBERT MICHELLE H
Honorable SMITH MATTHEW P
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Honorable SIBERT MICHELLE H
Sitting En Banc Commencing at
0:00 AM
| 3 | 0:00 AM | 2024-03921 |
Plaintiff: J C
Defendant: PAIN RELIEF CHIROPRACTIC PC; STINAS HERBCRAFT AND MASSAGE THERAPY
JOHN CROUMER, ESQ.; KONSTANTINOS PATSIOPOULOS, ESQ.; KUTZ JAMES J, ESQ.; NATHANIEL FOOTE, ESQ.; VERONICA N HUBBARD, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed August 15, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed October 30, 2024 by VERONICA N HUBBARD
|
| 6 | 0:00 AM | 2024-00457 |
Plaintiff: US BANK TRUST NATIONAL ASSOCIATION AS TRUSTEE OF THE LB-RANCH SERIES V TRUST
Defendant: GEORGIANNA SUE NEUFER KNOWN HEIR OF HELEN M FOULTZ DECEASED; KELLI ANN BEAVER KNOWN HEIR OF HELEN M FOULTZ DECEASED; RANDY WILLIAM FOLTZ KNOWN HEIR OF HELEN M FOULTZ DECEASED; KATHLEEN R FOULTZ KNOWN HEIR OF HELEN M FOULTZ DECEASED; SCOTT ALLEN FOULTZ SR KNOWN HEIR HELEN M FOULTZ DECEASED; UNKNOWN HEIRS SUCCESSORS ASSIGNS AND ALL PERSONS FIRMS OR ASSOCIATIONS CLAIMING RIGHT TITLE OR INTEREST FROM OR UNDER HELEN
Ian Yorke, Esq.; MICHAEL J CLARK, ESQ.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed August 20, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| 7 | 0:00 AM | 2024-05775 |
Plaintiff: WILLIAM RAY
Defendant: FOX SUBACUTE AT MECHANICSBURG LLC ; ABC CORP 1 THROUGH 10; FOX SUBACUTE MANAGEMENT INC; JOHN/JANE DOES 1 THROUGH 10; XYZ CO 1 THROUGH 10
Christine C Blair, Esq.; Jessica Foster, Esq.; Philip Mintz, Esq.; WILLIAM J MUNDY, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed August 23, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 8 | 0:00 AM | 2024-08063 |
Plaintiff: BRIANA STELZER
Defendant: NATHANIEL FUNK
P RICHARD WAGNER, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS OF DEFT
Listed September 3, 2024 by P RICHARD WAGNER
|
| 9 | 0:00 AM | 2024-07989 |
Plaintiff: AMERICAN EXPRESS NATIONAL BANK
Defendant: JOHN MISTISHIN
JASON E STRAND, ESQ.; KIRSTEN R ARMSTRONG, ESQ.; Michael F McGuigan Esq; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT
Listed September 4, 2024 by BY ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 11 | 0:00 AM | 2024-08516 |
Plaintiff: DISCOVER BANK
Defendant: CINDY HOCKLEY
Erin R Grady Esq; JASON E STRAND, ESQ.; Michael F McGuigan Esq; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS PURSUANT TO PARCP 1028
Listed September 11, 2024 by ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH
|
| 12 | 0:00 AM | 2024-01418 |
Plaintiff: CHRISTOPHER HICK
Defendant: BEN EHRSAM
JESSICA S HOSENPUD, ESQ.; KEITH E KENDALL, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS AMENDED COMPLAINT BY JESSICA S HOSENPUD ATTY FOR DEFT
Listed September 12, 2024 by BY JESSICA S HOSENPUD ESQUIRE
|
| 15 | 0:00 AM | 2022-05757 |
Plaintiff: MICHAEL ROYSTER
Defendant: WILLIAM NICKLOW ET AL
FRANCIS PRYZBYLKOWSKI, ESQ.; TIMOTHY A HOLMES, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed September 16, 2024 by ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 16 | 0:00 AM | 2024-04509 |
Plaintiff: LEE ANN HUEBNER; DEAN HUEBNER
Defendant: ROBERT SCHMITT JR.; PARAMOUNT FENCE LLC
BRANDON A SWARTZ, ESQ.; BRYAN M FERRIS, ESQ.; JULIA ANNE MORRISON, ESQ.; Shannon Harkins, Esq.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS OF DEFENDANTS ROBERT SCHMITT JR AND PARAMOUNT FENCE LLC
Listed September 18, 2024 by SHANNON HARKINS ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 18 | 0:00 AM | 2024-08629 |
Plaintiff: CITIBANK N A
Defendant: SCOTT HARVEY
Ilana Zion, Esq.; MICHAEL R LIPINSKI, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.; SEAN STEVENS, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS PURSUANT TO PA RCP 1028
Listed September 23, 2024 by ROBERT KLINGENSMITH ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 19 | 0:00 AM | 2024-08628 |
Plaintiff: CITIBANK N A
Defendant: JODI SADLER
Ilana Zion, Esq.; MICHAEL R LIPINSKI, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.; SEAN STEVENS, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS PURSUANT TO PA RCP 1028
Listed September 23, 2024 by ROBERT KLINGENSMITH ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 24 | 0:00 AM | 2024-04248 |
Plaintiff: BANK OF AMERICA
Defendant: ELLEN J KITZ
JONATHAN P CAWLEY, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.; ROBERT L BAROSKA III, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed October 8, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 25 | 0:00 AM | 2020-05447 |
Plaintiff: PORTFOLIO RECOVERY ASSOCIATES LLC
Defendant: RICHARD CONDON
CARRIE GERDING, ESQ.; GREGORY J BABCOCK, ESQ.; MICHAEL J PYKOSH, ESQ.
Listed October 31, 2024 by
|
| 26 | 0:00 AM | 2023-05319 |
Plaintiff: CITIBANK NA
Defendant: LUKE E CREAMER
Ilana Zion, Esq.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.; ROBERT M KLINE, ESQ.
Listed October 31, 2024 by
|
| 27 | 0:00 AM | 2023-06904 |
Plaintiff: MCLP ASSET COMPANY INC
Defendant: ESTATE OF NATASCHA THOMAS AKA NATASCHA WALLACE; JAMES THOMAS; JESSE A WALLACE
Jacqueline F. McNally, Esq.; NATHAN C WOLF, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.; WILLIAM E MILLER, ESQ.
Listed October 31, 2024 by
|
| 28 | 0:00 AM | 2023-04100 |
Plaintiff: KATHERINE STRAIT; DANIEL STRAIT
Defendant: GRAYSON RALPH BOWERS
Ann Rinear Dougherty Esquire; BREYMEIER JOSEPH A, ESQ.; KELLY TREWELLA, ESQ.; Kristina Bergsten, Esq.
PER ORDER OF COURT
Listed November 5, 2024 by
|
| 29 | 0:00 AM | 2023-02906 |
Plaintiff: CAVALRY SPV I LLC
Defendant: APRIL SISKO
DAVID J APOTHAKER, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
Listed June 20, 2023 by
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed November 20, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
Removed from Argument
| 1 | removed | 2022-05593 |
Plaintiff: KEITH R MARTIN
Defendant: CARLISLE CUSTOMS & CLASSICS; CARLISLE AUTO BODY & COLLISION INC; CARLISLE CUSTOMS & CLASSICS HOLDINGS LLC; VINCENT P SCALAVINO
Alexandria Ebbert, Esq.; EVAN C PAPPAS, ESQ.; VANESSA M SCALAVINO, ESQ.
LISTED PER 4/11/2024 ORDER OF COURT - DOCKET ENTRY CREATED FOR LIST PURPOSES
Listed April 16, 2024 by BY THE COURT: MICHELLE H SIBERT J -
|
| Reason: Settled | |||
| 4 | removed | 2022-07227 |
Plaintiff: IVC INC D/B/A INDUSTRIAL VALLEY CONTROLS
Defendant: PRESBYTERIAN DEVELOPMENT LLC; 2500 GETTYSBURG ASSOCIATES LLC
Aaron Scheibelhut, Esq.; John A. Gagliardi, Esq.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS COMPLAINT UPON MECHANICS LIEN
Listed August 16, 2024 by AARON M SCHEIBELHUT ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| Reason: Settled | |||
| 10 | removed | 2024-07386 |
Plaintiff: MARINER FINANCE
Defendant: KAHLEE HUNTER
PETERS JR JOHN C, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS PURSUANT TO PARCP 1028
Listed September 6, 2024 by ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH
|
| Reason: Off - March 2025 | |||
| 13 | removed | 2024-01105 |
Plaintiff: HALEY WEIBLEY
Defendant: SYNCREON AMERICA INC
BRIAN C CAFFREY, ESQ.; Erica Shikunov, Esq.; Jeffrey Schott, Esq.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed September 13, 2024 by ATTY FOR DEFT
KELLY SERVICES, INCS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO SYNCREONS JOINDER COMPLAINT
Listed September 16, 2024 by NIYAH MORGAN DANTZLER ATTY FOR KELLY SERVICES INC
|
| Reason: Praecipe to remove | |||
| 14 | removed | 2023-07522 |
Plaintiff: ZACHARY WHITTAKER; BILLY JO WHITTAKER
Defendant: YONG LU; SUIWAI CHENG; SUIWAI CHENG; YONG LU
CHRISTINE L. LINE, ESQ.; CORY A LESHNER, ESQ.; LISA MARY-FRANCES HOPKINS, ESQ.
DEFTS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed September 13, 2024 by CORY LESHNER ESQ ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| Reason: off - Court Order | |||
| 20 | removed | 2024-07124 |
Plaintiff: MICHELLE R ARBITELL PSY.D, A.B.P.P.
Defendant: LEO GRYGIEL
CRAIG L FISHMAN, ESQ.; GEORGE H EAGER, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed September 24, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| Reason: P.O.'s withdrawn | |||
| 22 | removed | 2020-05740 |
Plaintiff: JANE BETZ EXECUTRIX OF THE EESTATE OF RICHARD M BETZ AND IN HER OWN RIGHT
Defendant: UPMC PINNACLE WEST SHORE HOSPITAL; UPMC PINNACLE HOSPITAL
Andrew M Marth Esq; BAKER LAURALEE B, ESQ.; James E. Beasley, Jr., Esq.; Tasha Nankerville, Esq.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed September 27, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| Reason: Move to February | |||
| 23 | removed | 2023-05178 |
Plaintiff: KEVIN LECHNER
Defendant: ARIKA B MATTHEWS
JASON E PIATT, ESQ.; MELISSA L KELSO, ESQ.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed September 27, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| Reason: Removed Court Order | |||
| 2 | removed | 2024-07133 |
Plaintiff: KRISTOPHER COON
Defendant: THE AMERICAN LEGION POST 109; JAMIE LETHIECQ
JASON A STATLER, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed August 14, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
DEFTS PO'S
Listed October 7, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| Reason: withdrawn | |||