Office of the Court Administrator
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
1 Courthouse Square, Carlisle, PA 17013
Phone (717) 240-6200
Toll Free 1-888-697-0371 x6200
Fax (717) 240-6460
Email - courtadmin@ccpa.net
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
1 Courthouse Square, Carlisle, PA 17013
Phone (717) 240-6200
Toll Free 1-888-697-0371 x6200
Fax (717) 240-6460
Email - courtadmin@ccpa.net
ARGUMENT COURT
Friday, March 21, 2025
Cases appearing on the Argument Court List will be heard as follows:
COURTROOM 3
Honorable GUIDO EDWARD E
Honorable SMITH MATTHEW P
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Honorable GUIDO EDWARD E
Honorable SMITH MATTHEW P
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Sitting En Banc Commencing at
9:30 AM
| 16 | 9:30 AM | 2019-00727 |
Plaintiff: MCCOY BROS INC
Defendant: NESLUND PROPERTIES LLC
Coulter D Ebbert, Esq.; DEAN F PIERMATTEI, ESQ.; Jill Neary Weikert, Esq.; MATTHEW CHABAL III, ESQ.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed December 18, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
DEFT/OWNERS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT & TO STRIKE MECHANICS LIEN
Listed January 13, 2025 by MATTHEW CHABAL III
|
| 18 | 9:30 AM | 2023-03627 |
Plaintiff: JOLENE N BUCKLEY
Defendant: RANDALL A MCKEE; FEDERAL EXPRESS CORPORATION; RANDALL MCKEE; THE VANGUARD GROUP INC
ANTHONY T MCBETH, ESQ.; SALLY J WINDER, ESQ.
PER ORDER OF COURT
Listed December 19, 2024 by
|
| 22 | 9:30 AM | 2020-05834 |
Plaintiff: HAMILTON-MYERS POST 6070 VETERANS OF FORIEGN WARS
Defendant: KAREN LYNN LENTZ; WILLIAM M MORROW SR; RAY SHAFFER SWARTZ II
MELISSA L KELSO, ESQ.; SCOTT P STEDJAN, ESQ.; STACY B WOLF, ESQ.
MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS
Listed January 2, 2025 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
DEFTS LENTZ MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON PLEADING
Listed February 5, 2025 by JEFFREY SCHOTT
|
| 26 | 9:30 AM | 2022-08935 |
Plaintiff: MONEYLINE LENDING LLC
Defendant: TREYSTA TECHONOLOGY MANAGEMENT
CLAIRE A MURTHA, ESQ.; MICHAEL A PIPA, ESQ.; PETER J RUSSO, ESQ.; ROLF E KROLL, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed February 6, 2025 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
BRIEFS ONLY
Honorable GUIDO EDWARD E
Honorable SMITH MATTHEW P
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Honorable GUIDO EDWARD E
Honorable SMITH MATTHEW P
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Sitting En Banc Commencing at
0:00 AM
| 1 | 0:00 AM | 2024-11223 |
Plaintiff: DISCOVER BANK
Defendant: CHRISTOPHER STEVICK
KIRSTEN R ARMSTRONG, ESQ.; Michael F McGuigan Esq; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed November 14, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 2 | 0:00 AM | 2024-10732 |
Plaintiff: JPMORGAN CHASE BANK N/A
Defendant: ANDREA ADAMS
Ian Michael Lauer, Esq.; James A HOLZMAN, Esq.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS PURSUANT TO PA RCP 1028
Listed November 18, 2024 by ROBERT KLINGENSMITH TTY FOR DEFT
|
| 4 | 0:00 AM | 2024-10497 |
Plaintiff: ATHANASIOS T MAZIAS; EVANGELIA MAZIAS
Defendant: RICHARD DILLOW
Bedrudin Becirovic, Esq.; JOSEPH G MUZIC JR, ESQ.; Kevin Packer, Esq.
DEFT, RICHARD DILLOWS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO RECKLESSNESS IN PLFFS COMPLAINT
Listed November 19, 2024 by KEVIN PACKER ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 5 | 0:00 AM | 2024-05949 |
Plaintiff: WILLIAM E BENNER III
Defendant: BLUE MOUNTAIN ANESTHESIA ASSOCIATES
Coulter D Ebbert, Esq.; MICHAEL D PIPA, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed November 21, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 6 | 0:00 AM | 2024-05951 |
Plaintiff: WILLIAM E BENNER III
Defendant: JULIO SOLA
Coulter D Ebbert, Esq.; MICHAEL D PIPA, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed November 21, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 7 | 0:00 AM | 2024-01870 |
Plaintiff: NEWREZ LLC DBA SHELLPOINT MORTGAGE SERVICING
Defendant: ZACHARY M DUGAN
Cierra-Zadiyah Mendez, Esq.; Kayleigh Zeron, Esq.; M TROY FREEDMAN, ESQ.; Nicole Rizzo, Esq.; Zachary DuGan, Esq.
PLFFS MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS
Listed November 22, 2024 by TROY FREEDMAN ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| 9 | 0:00 AM | 2024-07299 |
Plaintiff: WARD EXCAVATING LLC
Defendant: LINLO PROPERTIES XVI LLC
KATHLEEN MISTURAK-GINGRICH KATHLEEN, ESQ.; RONALD H POLLOCK JR, ESQ.
OF WARD EXCAVATING LLC TO PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS OF LINLO PROPERTIES XVI LLC
Listed December 2, 2024 by KATHLEEN MISTURAK GINGRICH
|
| 11 | 0:00 AM | 2024-11234 |
Plaintiff: DISCOVER BANK
Defendant: MATT R MCCREA
MATTHEW D URBAN, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS PURSUANT TO PARCP 1028
Listed December 4, 2024 by ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH
|
| 12 | 0:00 AM | 2024-09048 |
Plaintiff: SMITH RICHARD
Defendant: LAUGHNER CONTRACTOR SERVICES; LAUGHNER TRAVIS; LAUGHNER CONTRACTING SERVICES
Jill Neary Weikert, Esq.
MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS
Listed December 10, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR PLFF
|
| 15 | 0:00 AM | 2024-10058 |
Plaintiff: KASHIF ELLIS
Defendant: MICHAEL GOURLEY; CORRECTION OFFICER MOORE ; CORRECTIONOFFICER DOLAN ; LIEUTENANT ELWELL; CO LOWE; SERGENT TIMPE; UNIT MANAGER MILLER
MAZESKI VINCENT R, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed December 16, 2024 by ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 17 | 0:00 AM | 2024-12067 |
Plaintiff: JPMORGAN CHASE BANK N/A
Defendant: PATRICIA M WITMER
Ian Michael Lauer, Esq.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS PURSUANT TO PARCP 1028
Listed December 18, 2024 by ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH
|
| 19 | 0:00 AM | 2024-05174 |
Plaintiff: DISCOVER BANK
Defendant: MORGAN ESSIG
MATTHEW W POMY, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed December 19, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 20 | 0:00 AM | 2024-11669 |
Plaintiff: UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY AS ASSIGNEE AND SUBROGEE OF CAPITAL PLAZA ASSOCIATES LP ; UTICA MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY A/S/O RJ LUTES INSURANCE AGENCY
Defendant: OPTILUMEN INC; ABC CORPORATION; JANE/JOHN DOE; HORNUNG’S TRUE VALUE INC
Anthony Ziccardi, Esq.; CHOMKO JEFFREY J, ESQ.; JEFFREY M POLLOCK, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed December 30, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 21 | 0:00 AM | 2023-06048 |
Plaintiff: JEREMY CRUZ
Defendant: SCI CAMP HILL FACILITY MANAGER
LAUREN GILIUS, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed December 30, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| 27 | 0:00 AM | 2022-07796 |
Plaintiff: JOHN COMINSKY
Defendant: DAVID HEISEY
Frank C Sluzis, Esq.; MICHAEL J PYKOSH, ESQ.; NICHOLAS J WACHINSKI, ESQ.; STEPHEN G HELD, ESQ.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed February 12, 2025 by BY ATTY FOR PLFF
|
Removed from Argument
| 3 | removed | 2024-07806 |
Plaintiff: MELANIE R YADOUGA AS ADMINISTRATRIX OF THE ESTATE OF VALERIE L NEYER DECEASED
Defendant: PENN STATE HEALTH HAMPDEN MEDICAL CENTER; MD ROBERT DELROSARIO; MD GERALD FERRY; MD ANTHONY C LEWIS; MD VIRGINIA E SMITH
APRIL C SIMPSON, ESQ.; Carol M Cowhey, Esq.; CATHLEEN KELLY REBAR, ESQ.; Coulter D Ebbert, Esq.; DANIEL P MARTZ, ESQ.; Edvard L. Wilson, Esq.; Janene Druck, Esq.; MATTHEW J SCANLON, ESQ.; MICHAEL D PIPA, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed November 18, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS AMENDED COMPLAINT OF DEFT GERALD FERRY MD BY ATTY FOR
Listed November 18, 2024 by DANIEL MARTZ ATTY FOR DEFT
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS OF DEFT VIRGINIA E SMITH MD TO PLFFS AMENDED COMPLAINT BY ATTY FOR
Listed November 18, 2024 by CATHLEEN KELLY REBAR ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| Reason: Praecipe filed 2/11 | |||
| 10 | removed | 2023-04841 |
Plaintiff: PLANET HOME HEALTHCARE LLC
Defendant: CLAREMONT NURSING AND REHABILITATION CENTER LLC; ALLAIRE HEALTH SERVICES; ALLAIRE HEALTH SERVICES LLC; CLAREMONT NURSING AND REHABILITATION
GINA M LOMBARDO, ESQ.; R James Kravitz, Esq.; Randall Schauer, Esq.; STEVEN HOWELL, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS OF CLAREMONT AND ALLAIRE TO PLFFS SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed December 2, 2024 by R JAMES KRAVITZ
DEFT PRELIMINARY OBJECTINS
Listed December 27, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR PLFF
DEFT PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed January 2, 2025 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| Reason: Moved to May | |||
| 13 | removed | 2024-10207 |
Plaintiff: UNITED FINANCIAL CASUALTY COMPANY
Defendant: DANNY S SARABIA; XPO LOGISTICS FREIGHT INC
CAMERON DEANE, ESQ.; Jessica G Lucas, Esq.; MICHAEL J DOUGHERTY, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed December 10, 2024 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| Reason: Praecipe filed 2/28 | |||
| 14 | removed | 2024-00668 |
Plaintiff: CITIBANK N A
Defendant: KEITH E AUCKER
MICHAEL R LIPINSKI, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.; SEAN STEVENS, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS PURSUANT TO PA RCP 1028
Listed December 12, 2024 by ROBERT KLINGENSMITH ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| Reason: Praecipe filed 2/26 | |||
| 24 | removed | 2020-05740 |
Plaintiff: JANE BETZ EXECUTRIX OF THE EESTATE OF RICHARD M BETZ AND IN HER OWN RIGHT
Defendant: UPMC PINNACLE WEST SHORE HOSPITAL; UPMC PINNACLE HOSPITAL
Andrew M Marth Esq; BAKER LAURALEE B, ESQ.; James E. Beasley, Jr., Esq.; Tasha Nankerville, Esq.
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT OF DEFTS
Listed January 30, 2025 by LAURALEE B BAKER
|
| Reason: Praecipe filed | |||
| 23 | removed | 2021-03280 |
Plaintiff: ROY SHANAFELTER
Defendant: ENVIRODYNE SYSTEMS INC; ERIC BUSHEY; ROBERT E SHEKER P.E.
Amanda L Hennessey, Esq.; ANTHONY J FOSCHI, ESQ.; Coulter D Ebbert, Esq.; JOSHUA J BOVENDER, ESQ.; Louis Fiorilla, Esq.
PLFFS MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE ACTIONS
Listed January 21, 2025 by COULTER D EBBERT
|
| Reason: Court order - stricken | |||
| 25 | removed | 2023-07151 |
Plaintiff: TYLER BROWN
Defendant: THE PEP BOYS - MANNY MOE JACK LLC; CBRE GROUP INC ; FACILITYSOURCE HOLDING LLC; ROXANNE L CRAWFORD EXECUTRIX FOR THE ESTATE OF RODNEY L WITMER D/B/A AR WITCO
Brian J Hinkle, Esq.; Joan Marie Etzweiler, Esq.; JULIANN SCHWEGLER KELLEY, ESQ.; KELLY LLP TOOMEY C SCOTT, ESQ.; LLOYD SUSAN SMITH, ESQ.
DEFTS CBRE GROUP INC AND FACILITYSOURCE HOLDINGS LLCS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed February 5, 2025 by SUSAN LLOYD
|
| Reason: May | |||
| 8 | removed | 2023-04876 |
Plaintiff: MATTHEW RAPOPORT
Defendant: NAPA TRANSPORTATION INC
CUMMINGS DERREK W, ESQ.; LARRY A WEISBERG, ESQ.; Leah A. Lewis, Esq.; Michael Bradley, Esq.; Steve Mahan, Esq.; Susan Valinis, Esq.; Tracey McDevitt Hagan, Esq.
DEFT, NAPA TRANSPORTATION INCS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFFS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO NAPA TRANSPORTATION INCS NEW MATTER TO PLFFS COMPLAINT
Listed November 25, 2024 by SUSAN VALINIS ATTY FOR DEFT
|
| Reason: . | |||