Office of the Court Administrator
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
1 Courthouse Square, Carlisle, PA 17013
Phone (717) 240-6200
Toll Free 1-888-697-0371 x6200
Fax (717) 240-6460
Email - courtadmin@ccpa.net
ARGUMENT COURT
Friday, May 29, 2026
Cases appearing on the Argument Court List will be heard as follows:
COURTROOM 2
Honorable MASLAND ALBERT H
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Honorable SACAVAGE ALEXANDRA E
Sitting En Banc Commencing at
9:00 AM
1 9:00 AM 2017-09680
Plaintiff: GUISSEPPI FORGIONNE
Defendant: JOHN A GURDAK; UNCLE DAVES BRASS TRAINS
DAVID C DAGLE, ESQ.
PER ORDER
Listed March 11, 2020 by
10 9:00 AM 2025-12631
Plaintiff: PRITAM KANDEL
Defendant: PRAKASH PATHAK
MATTHEW OWENS, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed January 28, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed February 27, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR PLFF
PER ORDER OF COURT
Listed April 29, 2026 by
11 9:00 AM 2025-09503
Plaintiff: SOUTHFIELD CROSSING HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION
Defendant: SOUTHFIELD CROSSING HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION PHASE II
Alexis McConville, Esq.; ROLF E KROLL, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO COMPLAINT
Listed February 2, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
PER ORDER OF COURT
Listed April 30, 2026 by
12 9:00 AM 2023-01563
Plaintiff: BLANCA TORRENT; ARNALDO TORRENT
Defendant: UPMC PINNACLE HOSPITALS D/B/A UPMC PINNACLE WEST SHORE
CHARLES JAY SCHLEIFER, ESQ.; KEVIN C MCNAMARA, ESQ.; Laura Daube, Esq.; Scott Schleifer Esquire
DEFT MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGEMENT
Listed February 2, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
PER ORDER OF COURT
Listed March 20, 2026 by
22 9:00 AM 2026-00566
Plaintiff: KARA GUSSLER
Defendant: NORTH NEWTON TOWNSHIP BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
ZACHARY M RICE, ESQ.
PER ORDER OF COURT
Listed March 3, 2026 by
PER ORDER OF COURT
Listed April 6, 2026 by
25 9:00 AM 2024-06859
Plaintiff: WITKOWSKI NOVEMBER LLC
Defendant: ORTHOPEDIC SURGEONS LTD; ORTHOPEDIC INSTITUTE OF PA
Aaron Scheibelhut, Esq.; MATTHEW CHABAL III, ESQ.; MEGAN C HUFF, ESQ.; RICHARD B DRUBY, ESQ.
Listed April 23, 2026 by
BRIEFS ONLY
Honorable MASLAND ALBERT H
Honorable HYAMS CARRIE E
Honorable SACAVAGE ALEXANDRA E
Sitting En Banc Commencing at
0:00 AM
4 0:00 AM 2025-12444
Plaintiff: ANNETTE S LONG
Defendant: BERRIER PROPERTIES LLC
ANNA KNYCH, ESQ.; BRIAN K ZELLNER, ESQ.; DAVID R GALLOWAY, ESQ.; Dominic Giovanniello, Esq.; MICHAEL T TRAXLER, ESQ.; Mr. Erik Hume, Esq.
DEFT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFF'S COMPLAINT
Listed January 19, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
DEFT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFF'S AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed February 27, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
5 0:00 AM 2025-12554
Plaintiff: PERFECTLY SOUND RENOVATIONS LLC
Defendant: BHAGI BARAILY
BRIAN K ZELLNER, ESQ.
DEFENDANT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT
Listed January 22, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed January 30, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
6 0:00 AM 2025-12727
Plaintiff: CITIBANK N A
Defendant: GEORGE MAILLE
PAUL JOHN KLEMM, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS PURSUANT TO PARCP 1028
Listed January 26, 2026 by ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH
7 0:00 AM 2025-12438
Plaintiff: SOUTHERN INSURANCE COMPANY OF VIRGINIA A/S/O TIL KSHETRI AND SUNITA KSHETRI
Defendant: BERKS CONSTRUCTION CO INC A/K/A BERKS HOMES; FLUIDMASTER INC; JSL MECHANICAL INC
BENJAMIN P NOVAK, ESQ.; EUGENE BEDERMAN, ESQ.; Michael Toczyski, Esq.; Shannon Harkins, Esq.; STEPHANIE E LOMBARDO, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed January 26, 2026 by ATTY FOR DEFT
8 0:00 AM 2025-12466
Plaintiff: NCB MANAGEMENT SERVICES INC
Defendant: TANESHA SIMSWHITAKER
DEMETRIOS H TSAROUHIS, ESQ.; Holden Sweger, Esq.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed January 26, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
13 0:00 AM 2022-08495
Plaintiff: SUSAN L HUTCHISON ADMINX; SUSAN L HUTCHISON
Defendant: JANEY L GUNN; JAMES A PENNINGTON; PENNSYLVANIA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION ; PPL ELECTRIC UTILITIES CORPORATION
Andrew R Benedit, Esq.; JEREMY S MONTGOMERY, ESQ.; JOHN A STATLER, ESQ.; SCOTT D MCCARROLL, ESQ.; VALERIE WILLIAMS, ESQ.; WARD A RIVERS, ESQ.
DEFT JAMES A. PENNINGTON D/B/A PENNINGTON TREE EXPERTS A/K/A PENNINGTON TREE EXPERT SERVICE'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed February 3, 2026 by BY ATTY WARD S. RIVERS, ESQ. FOR DEFT JAMES A. PENNINGTON D/B/A PENNINGTON TREE EXPERTS, A/K/A PENNINGTON TREE EXPERT SERVICES
14 0:00 AM 2026-00221
Plaintiff: CAPITAL ONE NA
Defendant: CARL CALHOUN
Ernest Sarif, Esq.; Michael F McGuigan Esq; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
DEFTS PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS PURSUANT TO PARCP 1028
Listed February 5, 2026 by ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH
15 0:00 AM 2026-00124
Plaintiff: ROBERT S SANDERS
Defendant: LINDSY KENDALL; SERGEANT MR BERTOLLINI; SHANINQUA FELLS; ROSS MILLER; CHRIS SREBREO
Tara J Wikhian, Esq.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed February 9, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
16 0:00 AM 2025-12287
Plaintiff: KEYSTONE ARMS PHASE TWO LP
Defendant: RENEE BYRD
Aurora Lynd, Esq.; STEVEN M WILLIAMS, ESQ.
PLFF'S MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS PURSUANT TO PA.R.C.P. 1034
Listed February 12, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR PLFF
17 0:00 AM 2025-07836
Plaintiff: NCB MANAGEMENT SERVICES INC
Defendant: ASHLEY DAW
DAVID R GALLOWAY, ESQ.; DEMETRIOS H TSAROUHIS, ESQ.
DEFT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFF'S COMPLAINT
Listed February 12, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
PLFF'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO DEFT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS TO PLFF'S COMPLAINT
Listed February 24, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR PLFF
19 0:00 AM 2024-11069
Plaintiff: ONE RESTORED LLC D/B/A RESTORATION 1
Defendant: ANNA BOWEN; FRED BOWEN
Ashley Nicols Weber, Esq.; Colin James Butler, Esq.; RICHARD J SENECA, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed February 24, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
20 0:00 AM 2025-04599
Plaintiff: ASHLEIGH BENDER; ROBERT BENDER; FURNITURE & MATTRESS DISCOUNT KING INC
Defendant: ZACH WITTAKERD/B/A ZS KREATION
PETER J RUSSO, ESQ.
DEFT'S PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed February 25, 2026 by BY DEFT PRO SE
21 0:00 AM 2026-00548
Plaintiff: ENOLA FAMILY RESTAURANT LLC
Defendant: WERTZVILLE DINER LLC; AHMED DESOUKY
Abdulrehman Ahmed, Esq.; CHRISTOPHER T WILLIAMS, ESQ.; HUBERT X GILROY, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed February 26, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
23 0:00 AM 2025-10680
Plaintiff: ZACHARY WHITTAKER
Defendant: BOB BENDER
PETER J RUSSO, ESQ.
PER ORDER
Listed April 8, 2026 by IN RE: PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS - BY THE COURT: ALBERT H MASLAND PJ -
24 0:00 AM 2022-03290
Plaintiff: CAVALRY SPV I LLC
Defendant: CARA A SPAHR
DAVID J APOTHAKER, ESQ.; DEREK A MOATZ, ESQ.; Jordan Kurth, Esq.; Kelly J Adams, Esq.
PER ORDER OF COURT
Listed April 14, 2026 by
Removed from Argument
2 removed 2025-05692
Plaintiff: DISCOVER BANK; CAPITAL ONE NA
Defendant: LUCINDA SNOWBERGER
MATTHEW D URBAN, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS
Listed January 12, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
Reason: praecipe to remove
3 removed 2023-01008
Plaintiff: UPPER ALLEN TOWNSHIP
Defendant: STEPHEN J GUTSHALL; 1ST ADVANTAGE SETTLEMENT SERVICES INC; SHERRY M CASWELL; HOOVER ENGINEERING SERVICES INC; JOHN N PAPOUTSIS
Aurora Lynd, Esq.; Bingran Li, Esq.; ELIZABETH L MELAMED, ESQ.; FREDERICK M BREHM, ESQ.; J STEPHEN FEINOUR, ESQ.; JOSHUA D BONN, ESQ.; LAVERY FRANK J JR, ESQ.; LINUS FENICLE, ESQ.; MADISON BIERLEY, ESQ.; Matthew G. Laver, Esq.
THIRD PARTY DEFTS ST ADVANTAGE SETTLEMENT SERVICES INCS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGEMENT
Listed January 16, 2026 by MATTHEW G LAVER
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OF DEFT HOOVER ENGINEETING SERVICES INC
Listed January 16, 2026 by FREDERICK M BREHM
DEFT JOHN N. PAPOUTSIS, ESQ.'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Listed January 20, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
Reason: continued to 8/28
18 removed 2026-00276
Plaintiff: WAYNE A WEAVER
Defendant: BILLIE JEAN M WEAVER
QUINTINA M LAUDERMILCH, ESQ.
PRELIMINARY OBJECTION- IMPROPER VENUE
Listed February 17, 2026 by BY ATTY FOR DEFT
Reason: custody matter
9 removed 2025-08174
Plaintiff: CITIBANK N A
Defendant: DEBORAH GIRARD
Ilana Zion, Esq.; MICHAEL R LIPINSKI, ESQ.; ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH, ESQ.; SEAN STEVENS, ESQ.
TO AMENDED COMPLAINT
Listed January 27, 2026 by ROBERT D KLINGENSMITH
Reason: consent motion to strike